Back to All Events

COLUMBIA CLASSICS TALKS: André Rehbinder’s talk on "Physical and Rhetorical Exercise in the Prologue of the Phaedrus"

  • Department of Classics at Columbia University 1130 Amsterdam Avenue, 603 Hamilton Hall, MC 2861 New York, NY 10027 (map)

Friday, December 4, 2026

"Physical and Rhetorical Exercise in the Prologue of the Phaedrus" with André Rehbinder

  • 4:10 PM 5:30 PM

  • Department of Classics at Columbia University in the City of New York1130 Amsterdam Avenue, 603 Hamilton Hall, MC 2861New York, NY 10027

  • Please note: In order to enter Columbia's campus, you will need either a valid CUID or a guest access QR code. To receive guest access, please email the department.

Abstract: The prologue of the Phaedrus intertwines three distinct discussions: the proper way to exercise the body, the right method for reciting Lysias’ speech, and the just relationship to myths. These discussions are closely mirrored by the physical journey of the two characters, who walk from the center of Athens to a beautiful countryside setting outside the city walls. I will argue that Plato unifies these three thematic strands through the central notion of exercise—μελέτη.

On one hand, the medical theories of Acumenus and Herodicus, and on the other, the rhetoric of Lysias, both prescribe forms of exercise that Plato ultimately rejects. The long walks championed by the former and the repetitive recitations demanded by the latter entirely consume their practitioners’ time. Consequently, this prevents them from dedicating themselves to truly essential pursuits, such as the self-knowledge demanded by the Delphic maxim.

Plato illustrates the rejection of these exercises by having Phaedrus adopt the technical jargon of physicians and rhetoricians, which Socrates then subtly mocks in his responses. Furthermore, the physical postures of the characters—first walking through the countryside, then lying down in the grass—echo this double condemnation of the unsound sophistication found in both Herodicus’ medicine and Lysias’ rhetoric. Ultimately, these two flawed practices serve as the negative counterparts to the genuine Hippocratic medicine and Periclean rhetoric praised at the end of the dialogue.